Every failure mode we've documented, in the order they tend to occur. Complete this checklist for every production containing redactions. A single unchecked failure is grounds to stop the production.
The one that keeps us up at night"We accidentally removed every redaction in the production set." Take a breath. Now open Section 3, item 3.4, and start there. It's usually a text-layer problem, not a redaction-layer problem.
Section 1 · Reviewer-Level QC
Section 2 · Image-Level QC
Section 3 · Text-Layer QC (Critical)
This is where productions fail
A redaction painted on the image is not a redaction of the searchable text layer. If you OCR before redacting, the text layer contains the words the image no longer shows. When opposing counsel searches, they find the redacted content in the text. Every time.
Section 4 · Native File QC
Section 5 · Family Consistency
Section 6 · Post-Ship Verification
Section 7 · Sign-off
All sections above are complete. If any item is unchecked or failed, the production is HELD and returned to the responsible team.